|
GLOBAL
SENSE:
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
PART
I:
MINDFUL
SELF RULE AND MODERN
REPUBLICS
- .
1.
Personal Democracy
- .
2.
Origin and Rise of
Government
- .
3.
Constitutional
Republics
- .
4.
A House Divided Against
Itself
- .
5.
Clear and Present
Dangers
- .
6.
Genuine
Democracy
.
- .
|
The
discipline of desire is the
background of character.
- John Locke
|
Chapter
1. Personal Democracy
- What
does "mindful self rule" and "personal
democracy" mean to you in terms of your
own growth as a person?
.
- Discuss
the dynamics of the interactive
Communication Model and the process of
"sense making." How does your own
mental map of reality shape your daily
life choices?
.
- Can
you name instances when "split
perceptions" prevented you from seeing
a truth about yourself, other people or
a situation?
.
- What
accounts for the public impact of
Common Sense in 1776?
.
- Compare
and contrast the philosophies of Hobbes
and Spinoza with those of Locke and
Rousseau. Where does Paine fit in?
.
- What
was the meaning of "natural law" for
Paine?
|
Government
is not reason; it is not
eloquent; it is force.
Like fire, it is a dangerous
servant and a fearful master.
- George
Washington
|
Chapter
2. Origin and Rise of
Government
- Thomas
Paine believed the best form of
government is the one most likely to
secure our freedom at the least
expense. How well do your local to
national governments meet this
criteria?
.
- Discuss
Paine's parable of an imaginary
community going from self rule to a
democracy, then to a republic, then
sliding into tyranny. At what stage is
your nation today?
.
- Discuss
any government that's decayed from
freedom to tyranny. What were the
cultural and political forces
involved?
.
- How
do breakdowns in communication between
the people and the government tend to
result in authoritarian
regimes?
|
The
fundamental principle of a free
government
is the equal representation of a
free people
- Mercy Otis
Warren
|
Chapter
3. Constitutional Republics
- How
is the British House of Lords like the
U.S. Senate?
.
- How
is the House of Commons like the U.S.
House of Representatives?
.
- Should
the U.S. House vote on Supreme Court
appointments?
.
- Discuss
McCarthyism in the U.S. during the
1950s and the forces that ended it.
What are the parallels to society
today?
.
- Discuss
the social and cultural impact of media
"consolidation." How can we ensure that
journalists report abuses of
power?
|
Whenever
a separation is made between
liberty
and justice, neither, in my
opinion, is safe.
- Edmund
Burke
|
Chapter
4. A House Divided Against
Itself
- Is
the "balance of powers" in the U.S.
Constitution still effective?
.
- Discuss
Thomas Paine's machine metaphor for how
government works. Do you agree or
disagree with his Industrial Age
analogy?
.
- How
does our situation today compare and
contrast to the fate of Charles I and
the causes of the English Civil
War?
.
- Discuss
the theory that a violent revolution
against any tyranny often produces
another tyranny. Please cite
examples.
|
Those
who would give up essential
liberty to purchase
a little temporary safety deserve
neither liberty nor safety.
- Benjamin Franklin
|
Chapter
5. Clear and Present
Dangers
- Discuss
Roosevelt's 1941 "four freedoms"
speech. Why is each freedom important
to individuals and society as a
whole?
.
- Do
you agree or disagree that the "war on
terrorism" chiefly has produced more
terrorists and made the world less safe
than before?
.
- Do
you believe or doubt the official
reasons given for the U.S.-led invasion
and occupation of Iraq? Was the war
justified?
.
- Do
you believe the USA PATRIOT Act is
unconstitutional and should be
repealed? Are we unduly sacrificing
liberty for security?
.
- Research
the Alien and Sedition Acts signed in
1798 by President John Adams. Compare
them to the modern Patriot Acts.
.
- Discuss
the author's worst case and best case
scenarios. What would be your own best
and worst case scenarios for today's
crisis?
|
That
government is best which governs
the least,
because its people discipline
themselves.
- Thomas Jefferson
|
Chapter
6. Genuine Democracy
- Why
has no modern nation ever tried direct
democracy? What stands in the way of
genuine democracy in your country?
.
- Is
humanity mature enough for government
by the consent of the governed? What
would help us become ready?
.
- Why
and how is genuine democracy becoming
more feasible?
|